Overview
Ben and Mark bring back Annalie, founder of Boulevard Recruiting and an early recruiter at Palantir and Figma, for a loose conversation about the tech job market. The talk starts with a friend's question about whether to take severance and job hunt now or stay put, then moves through short tenures, founder behavior under AI pressure, and how companies should think about hiring.
Key Takeaways
Annalie describes a K-shaped market. A small group of candidates, including recruiters, are getting poached with multiple offers and unusual pay, while other strong people struggle to land anything. She ties this to big tech layoffs running alongside heavy startup funding. She also admits that when Claude Cowork came out she briefly panicked about her business and started looking at retirement options. She says that kind of fear is now driving impulsive founder decisions across Silicon Valley.
Ben's view is that the market won't calm down, so waiting for stability is pointless. Mark pushes back on timing altogether. You can't time the job market any better than the stock market, he says, and joining a hot company right before an initial public offering (IPO) can leave your restricted stock units (RSUs) underwater. Figure out what you're optimizing for first.
On short tenures, Mark separates three groups. Some people take the first offer out of a scarcity mindset. Some are financially secure, find a bad fit, and leave. Some get pushed out early. Annalie has seen recent cases of people let go within months, often for vague "fit" reasons, sometimes because a new hire clashed with them or because they weren't adopting AI fast enough. Her read is that in startups, culture is the founder's personality, and founders under pressure are moving faster and more rashly than before.
Ben blames both sides. Candidates and hiring managers rush, neither is clear about what they want, and neither asks honestly whether the person can succeed in the role.
On hiring strategy, Ben argues the best talent bets are people the market hasn't priced in yet, the way soccer clubs develop their own players. Annalie notes that founders often demand candidates who meet all 10 criteria and stall as a result. She now hires more junior recruiters and runs a boot camp, partly because junior people are easier to retain in a tight market.
Practical Steps
- Before any job search, do the self-work: what you want your days to look like, which environments bring out your best, and where you want to be in five to ten years.
- Break a severance window into thirds. Use the first to decompress and get clear on goals, then run two job search "seasons" of three to four months each.
- Build each season around a candidate-market fit hypothesis (an idea from Phil Terry and the Never Search Alone community). Ask former colleagues and recruiters which roles you'd be an obvious fit for, by company size, domain, business model, and individual contributor (IC) versus manager track. If the first season doesn't land, revisit the hypothesis.
- Hiring managers: turn whatever you care about, such as AI adoption, into explicit interview questions, and drop anything that doesn't predict success.
- If a role is unfillable, map the market. Annalie's team counts how many candidates meet every criterion and shows founders what loosening one or two would open up, or proposes splitting the role into two hires.
- For small or bootstrapped teams, a part-time expert advisor paired with AI agents may beat a full-time hire.
Notable Quotes
"I don't think there's a safe place to go and chill and weather the storm while the change is happening. That's gone." - Ben
"Honestly, in startups, I think startup culture is the founder's personality." - Annalie
"You don't find the people everyone else wants already because they're priced in. You find the people who are not priced in yet and then you get them in." - Ben
Full Transcript
Alright, we're live. Annalie, thank you so much for coming back on the show. Yeah, I'm so excited to be here. welcome, welcome. I'm excited. Yeah, it depends on how we count it. This is your third time on the show. Although, if we want to be purists about this, this is maybe your second time properly recording with us in Riverside. And we did publish one of our conversations that we had a live audience for, which was really cool. Yeah, we did a little course. I think people can still find that in your podcast recordings. Yes. Right? I think, yeah. Yeah, I think we went deep on that. Leveraging a recruiter to your advantage. I think that's what we talked about. That was super fun. Yeah, I learn a lot from you every time we talk. And given how fast the market is moving right now, I'm sure there's a lot more that Mark and I are going to learn from you today. Obviously happy to share some of what we're seeing if that's interesting to you too. Yeah, I think it's been definitely over six months since we've done one of these in the market. From everything I'm seeing, it's definitely changing at least every six months right now. So I want to start with like a quick anecdote from a friend of mine and get kind of like a reaction from, I guess, both of you and just use that to kick off the conversation. So without divulging identity or confidentiality, a good friend of mine, product leader at a Like a big-ish company recently went through an acquisition, or let's call it in the process of going through an acquisition. The team has been offered a very generous, in my opinion, don't need to get into numbers, very generous severance package. And my friend contacted me and she's in, you know, She's like hey, should I take the money? And then hit the market now or do I stick around? And apparently the severance package is going to be available even if they get impacted by some kind of riff in like three months or six months. I don't know how much all that's like finalized, but it sounds like it's like, do I stay in the role? And if I get impacted by riff, I hit the market in the future. Do I leave now and basically hit the market now with plenty of breathing room? Or do I, you know, just like... Stay and try to succeed and, you know, make the most I can in this role and not even worry about like what's out in the market. And so by talking to her about it, I was like, you know, this actually just feels more like a question about assuming there's two pieces here. One is like, how excited are you about doing the job and like staying around in this post acquisition environment, which is kind of unrelated to the market. And then there's the market question, which is like, is it better for me to hit the market now, in three months, in six months, next year? And so I was like really itching to kind of have a conversation about the current market because I have a lot of thoughts that I want to be able to pinpoint with your help. And I'll obviously also get your thoughts. So like maybe I'll just open up with a question, which is, Do you think there's any advantage to someone in this market for basically hitting the market sooner than later based on how fast it's changing? That's kind of what I was trying to think through. This is the first time I'm thinking through this exact question. I had a related conversation with a friend that will also remain nameless at a company that was asking me, well, they had recently declined an offer from one of the AI Frontier companies. About six months ago, and since then they're like, oh, should I have taken it? And maybe I could still go back, but like maybe the company I'm with could double or triple in value. And then maybe I would have my retirement money and maybe I could just go out on my own and make money as a consultant. And it was just a really kind of all over the place exploratory conversation. And I think he was looking to me because I see so many startups in particular. And of course, you know, who is our competition being these AI frontier companies. And I think people do have so many options. The thing I will call out, though, is that the market, have you heard it referred to as in a K shape? It's like the haves and the have nots. I haven't heard the K-shape, but we've talked a lot about how there's almost like this top, you know, one, depends how you want to call it, top 0.1 or top 1%, whatever. People that are having lots of offers, lots of optionality, kind of getting paid the professional, you know, athlete kind of like comp packages. And there's, you know, like a big middle. And then there's like a growing amount of people at the bottom that are just like struggling to get any offers. So that's kind of like how we've talked about it. Yeah, and so the recruiting population I run in sees this most dramatically, I would say. I think we tend to represent the most dramatic parts of the market swinging because we are the growth engine of Silicon Valley. And so what we're seeing is a small pool of recruiters getting poached super aggressively and can get multiple offers really fast and can get unprecedented salaries. And at the same time, we've got really great recruiters. Who are in the market and struggling. And it's really, to me, a symbol that it seems that Silicon Valley is downsizing. I don't have the exact statistics to say that. But, you know, we just saw the news come out about Microsoft doing another huge layoff. And we're seeing tech companies, the larger ones, do these massive layoffs that keep coming. And then we're also seeing unprecedented funding going into the startups. And it's creating a really weird mixed market of haves and have-nots. And when you're in that group of people that gets a lot of traction, I feel very lucky to be in that group in terms of the sales funnel for our company. We're exploding. We can't scale to meet the demand. And so it's like a moment where if you have a good thing going, good for you. It's exciting. And I cannot predict where it's going to be in six months. I will say that six months ago, I personally was a lot more scared. And there's maybe a few different reasons for that. So the timing to me, I don't know if it was six months ago or when exactly Cloud Cowork came out. So it was one of those things where we were hearing through the technical PMs and certainly through the engineers. Oh, agents, agents, agents. And we're like, okay, sounds cool, but I can't code. I'm not going to go buy my Mac Mini or whatever. And... But I was jealous. I was like, that sounds cool. Someone else is doing your job. I've got this little tool over here to help me record my transcript or whatever, but it wasn't really that groundbreaking. And then when Claude Cowork came out and I'm ingesting my financial statements and it's like spitting out really beautiful analysis in like 10 seconds, I freaked out a little bit. It was like, oh, shit. Can I say shit? Yeah. You can say whatever you want. And I had a little panic. And I was literally like, what if everything blew up? What if everything got automated? What if nobody needs engineers anymore? And that starts to roll out. Like, of course, we recruit actually for product managers, designers, go-to-market folks. But engineering is a big population historically in tech. And that population is downsizing. And we are seeing startups higher and less volume engineers than they used to. That is absolutely a trend. And so I was thinking, well, if that's a large bread and butter for my company, what if we don't have any business? Am I prepared to retire now? I looked at all my assets. I had a real estate agent come through. I was shopping in Puerto Rico for a minute for a tax strategy play. And I just felt like I was like spiraling a little bit. And... Piece by piece, I started to step forward and gain comfort and really learn how it worked and find how it benefited my team. And the sales kept coming. And slowly I've released the fear that was in me. But I'll call out that that fear in me, I've seen everybody experience some version of that. And you see so much fear driving through Silicon Valley. And you're seeing it in the founders who are acting super impulsively. And you're seeing Silicon Valley churning with We had three people leaders exit their companies of our clients within a month. Not that they were all forced out or anything, but there is a churn and burn that's happening. And so the market has just been like super painful, I would say. It's like super competitive, in some ways exciting. People are grateful if they have a job. But this is all to say that I think for your friend, if they're in that group of people, it sounds like they could be if they got acquired. It was that they got acquired and thus got a severance or the option to stay. Was that the fact pattern? Yeah. So there's an acquisition. I got to dance this line gently here. Okay. There's a big, let's just call it a big kind of merger situation going on. And this friend of mine has a very strong amount of experience in a very specific kind of like domain. That I think is still, like there are companies for sure, like that need this domain. And it's like a very important part of like, you know, the way to call it, like people engage with certain parts of, I mean, I'm just dancing around it. Let's just say there's a lot of demand for the domain. And so my take is that experience, that domain experience is the kind, it fits the mold of like hyper credibility in a very specialized area. While also having really strong, just like foundational chops as like a product leader. And I think a willingness to roll up sleeves. And even though they've been in a people leadership position, I think an eagerness to kind of also get hands on again in product, but hasn't interviewed in over five years. So kind of feels a little trepidation about the current market and is hearing all these stories in the market about how tough the market is right now. And my take was like, I think it's not going to get any tougher, any less tough. I think it's only going to get... I don't think it can get less tough. Like, I don't think that's a possibility. I have not seen it this tough. And it's always been tough in Silicon Valley and in startups specifically. Wait, wait, you don't think it can get tougher or you don't think... No, I don't. You don't think it can get tougher? Okay, well... I can't imagine. I mean, what would be tougher is if... We start losing business and no one's getting offers and truly AI automated everything and that is not happening. Well, okay, here's a thought. Mark, this last thing I'll say and then I'm very curious to hear what you're thinking. It's just like I didn't say it's going to get tougher. I said it's going to be more like wild and unpredictable. So... I think it's only going to change faster than it's been changing. The pace of change is picking up. So basically, it's almost like the ground we're standing on to me right now feels like it's as solid as it's going to be for the foreseeable future. So if someone's worried about entering a job market where things are shifting really fast, I actually think it's better to enter the market now than it is to enter the market later, unless you think there's going to come a point where things start solidifying again. Again, this isn't how I think about, I don't know if that's the primary criteria that should determine whether you should enter the market and when, but if someone is primarily worried about entering a market that's overly volatile, I just don't know if it's going to calm down anytime soon. I just feel like that's the wrong question. I feel like you should first figure out what you want. What are you optimizing for? Are you optimizing for Are you optimizing for, like, securing as much wealth as possible? And are you securing for, like, building a skill set you think it's missing that's going to future-prove yourself? I think then after that, like, it's kind of the same with investing. It's like, it's really hard to time the market, right? Like, you just don't know what's going to happen. Like, you can join OpenAI, you can join Anthropic. It actually might be a terrible time to join those companies because like, you know, let's say they go public soon and, you know, your RSU and then like just drops, you know, they see churn right away and your RSUs are underwater. And all of a sudden you're just screwed because you have a huge tax bill and you lost a bunch of money. Like I know a bunch of people that had that problem when they joined the company. I mean, I'm ex-Figma. Our IPO was like, boom. Totally. Like that. Yeah. I mean, thankfully I was very early, so it was still a big win, but it was really dramatic. Yeah, that happens. And especially the closer you get to that window of S1 to going public. So I think that's happening. Mark, your point is really good. And you know what? That's where it started to get uneasy too. It was Figma's stock going like this. And I was just like, wow, this is really dramatic. I was looking at the stock every day. That was part of it because the financial statements were awesome. The revenue was growing. Every financial metric historically would have been rewarded. And I think it was just this fear probably also timed with Cloud Cowork, but just people being like, holy shit, where is B2B SaaS going? Totally. Yeah. The SaaSpocalypse narrative, you know, about like, everyone's going to build their own SaaS and no one's going to share Figma links anymore because you can just go straight to prototypes and, you know, yeah, go ahead, Mark. And then there's the other part of like the weirdness that happens when a company goes public, right? Like there's going to be people like it's just so weird. Like you're around people is like, hey, this person made 100 million and I only made five. Right. Like, I don't know if the person that made 100 million is going to be working super hard. Like, you know, like all of a sudden, you literally just. So I have a lot of these sorts of people in my circles between Figma and Palantir. So. It's interesting. It is definitely when you're talking about what you want, you have to do the math on your personal finances because the person who is set is going to act differently than the person who wants to secure their retirement. And then there's variations I've seen in my entrepreneur's community of some people want to retire fabulously wealthy. And I'm more like, I just want to middle class retire and not stop working early as possible, you know, but that has to be part of the math. And I would say that There's going to be different risk tolerances in terms of is this money certain or not? Because it's always applied with startups, for example, that you're going to walk away from bigger salaries and in exchange for the upside of equity, that is possible with nothing or a loss if you exercise early. So it's always a big question of personal finance and risk and something to consider with their financial planner to understand how seriously they consider some of these options. Understanding you could enter the market and not get what you were hoping. And then staying at the company is more of a sure bet. But if you have a little bit more flexibility, I think you start to play into, well, what do I want to be doing? You know, like what brings me joy? Am I going to be happy here? Is it worth taking a bet on myself and what I do every day? Is it worth taking a bet on myself and being an entrepreneur or consultant? We're seeing a big trend with that also. Yeah. Yeah. Go ahead, Mark. No, I was going to say that to me are the interesting questions. And I think that's like the first level of questioning that you need to do before you even like think about like timing the market or now is a good time or not. Like I think based on what you explained about your friend, they sound competent. They sound like they have a really unique skill set. And they're in that percent that could get something big. They could. So like if they, so they're going to figure it out either tomorrow or in six months. Like I just have like, you know, I mean, they probably will get punched in the face and the first couple of interviews if they're rusty, but. I told them it's going to be full of rejection regardless of when they go through it. It's going to be full of false starts where like they think something's going really well and then for some reason business, maybe the business case changes, the recruiter gets fired, the hiring manager gets fired. Like there's a there's a million things that can torpedo an interview process that are outside your control. So just like be prepared for like crazy choppy waters no matter what happens. But I said all things I said all things equal. I would take call it the first third of the severance package time to just like decompress and chill a little bit and like do a lot of introspection on like what you're looking for next to be really intentional. And then I would enter the first what I call like season of your job search. And I think of a season of a job searches where you spend call it three to four months, I think is a good amount of time for a season. And there's a core like hypothesis that you're bringing into your job search in that first season that is based on something Mark and I have talked a lot about. Analia, are you familiar with like the candidate market fit stuff that Phil Terry talks about? Phil was on Lenny's podcast. There's this like group called Never Search Alone. It's a community. But one of the core concepts, it's a book also. One of the core concepts, and I'm not going to do it full justice, but we'll link to it in the show notes, is... That's actually one of the first YouTube videos I send people who are about to like think about their job searches is Phil Terry's conversation with Lenny because I think it's so good. And one of the core concepts is this concept of like candidate market fit. And candidate market fit is basically, you know, let's say the three of us were like, you know, about to hit the job market. We would talk to people who we've worked with who know us and know what we're capable of, but ideally who are also somewhat in positions to understand the market, like maybe they're A level above the kind of level we want to go in or a level horizontal of the level we want to go in or the recruiters who are hiring for the kind of roles that we want to go for and try to kind of like figure out what's at that overlap between like where are we going to be hyper qualified in this market like what's going to be the no brainer kind of roles that we Can get like company size, domain, business model, all the IC versus people leader, all these kind of different factors, location even. And then to craft, and then you end up with something that like you talk to these people and they're like, yeah, that sounds like you should definitely like be able to like crush those. Like those opportunities would be perfect for you, right? And then you have this like thesis or this hypothesis that you bring to your job search, which is like, I'm only going to go for these types of roles. And that's your first season of your job search. And if you can get an awesome role you're excited about in your first season, amazing, right? That's obviously the best case scenario. But if you don't get those in your first season, you got to go back to the drawing board and be like, what did I learn? And you got to go through that process again. You're kind of like finding product market fit, but like candidate market fit. So that was my advice is basically take the first third to like figure out what you want to go after. Take the second third to do your first season of your search and then leave the third third for like your second season of your search. And then you're giving yourself basically two full like seasons of a job search before you start to like worry about like money, right? I'm curious if you guys would poke holes in that advice. Like is there anything that you would add or like change about that? No, I mean, I think that sounds pretty wise. I mean, I think. Yeah, I agree. I think the part that people skip that's like the biggest mistake that I see is like kind of start doing the research with other people before you go deep yourself first. Like I think you need to go and like kind of like A quest of who am I? What do I want? What do I want my days to look like? What type of environments bring the best version of me? Where do I want to be in five to 10 years? And is this like a stepping stone towards that or a total deviation that will like delay my timeline? And I think once you have clarity on that, then I think everything becomes much easier. And the thing that I'll say is that it's, Much harder said than done, right? Much easier said than done? Sorry, much easier said than done, yeah. Yeah, like it's, if you haven't done that before, having gone dead, like, yeah, having done that self-work, that discovery, it's not easy. And I think it's hard to separate with what you want and what you think people want out of you and what society tells you. It's cool. And I think that's, That's actually like the hardest thing right now. Like, and I even, as someone who I feel like I'm pretty attuned with kind of who am I and what I want and expressing myself and like being honest to myself, like, like I do see those people that get those crazy offers that working at the cutting edge and the frontier labs. And I'm just like, oh shit, like, should that be me? Like, it's just so easy. And then it just like takes some effort and discipline to be like, no, dude, like you, you, you kind of are where you want to be. And And you just block that out. Like that's not part of your plan, even though you could be doing that. I have two reactions, one for each of you. So with the first one being, I think realism is a real strength. I see a lot of people getting very, I get a lot of phone calls from people wanting to go out on their own and recruiting. And they have this dream. It's very trend, like it's a trend I've seen where I want to go advise on head of talent strategy. And I don't want to do this grind of sourcing and I don't want to do the recruiting operations or whatever the case may be. And they go out to do the thing that they're passionate about, but they can't find revenue. And one thing for me having scaled Boulevard was I went into it a lot more openly where I went the product market fit route of let me just try a bunch of things and see what sticks and what sticks in a high volume and keeps coming to me. And I really believe in the concept of choose your heart. So it's hard to work out, but it's hard to be fat, like choose your heart. Sorry if that's controversial, but that concept. True. That sounds like fat. It applies to a lot of situations. And in the case of scaling this company, it's extremely hard to recruit for startups. There's so much about it that is painful. And if I had my dream world, I probably wouldn't do it. I'd do it in an Bigger companies that have more brand recognition, where they have more structure and like the, you know, a lot of things I could say about that. But what I chose to not be hard was sales. And that could be something that keeps founders up at night. If you don't have sales and you're risking payroll and all these things, it's like choose your hardly optimized for sales. And that required really being a realist about my value in this market. That I... I was employee 38 at Figma and scaled Figma through series ABC. And Notion was one of my first clients. We scaled 20 to 65 employees. And naturally, that's what VCs want me to do. So I think being a realist can be a blessing if you can really embrace reality instead of fighting it and working with it, letting it work for you. And then... Can I just react to the first reaction? Do you want to say both reactions? Are you going to remember the second reaction to Mark? I don't know. I have ADHD, so we'll find out. Let's get your reaction to Mark out so we don't lose it, and then I'll ask my follow-up. Jeez, Ben. So patience, man. Oh, and then I just personally related to what you were saying, Mark, about... I have had super boundaries around what I'm going to do with my life and my time. And there have been really crazy opportunities that are confidential. But I've said no to some really crazy things. Things that even my husband would be like, why didn't you do that? That's insane. Or even just staying at Figment longer. That stock was crazy. But I've just been really protective of everything. I want to build my own thing. I want to build my company culture. I want to work remotely. I want to have more time with my family. And I have been fierce about protecting those boundaries. And so you do see some people saying no to the AI frontier companies that other people would kill to be at. And that's a very privileged position to be in, like good for them. But I was just relating to what you're saying about that. My reaction to your reactions is that they both feel kind of like flavors of like, there's like a theme to both of those reactions, which is like, actually, I think both of those are about being hyper realistic. I think the first part is about being hyper realistic about what your what the market like disproportionately values about you or like, you know, like for your startup experience growing like the the growth stage kind of like That's clearly where the market's like, honestly, you're like the number one person we're thinking about for this. Like that's what the market wants and is pulling you to do. So you went there, right? Like, you know, you're being realistic in the sense of where the demand is and where the sales are, which I think is super smart. And then I think the second part, which is also smart and realistic, is you're being realistic about what you want and you're being realistic about what you can commit to without feeling like you're falling behind and like, Other you're falling behind in other the past and so I just don't know how effective I am when I let that take over. Yeah. Can I? Go ahead, Mark. Yeah. Just one final thought there too. And I think that's one thing that I think the, to like the US society in general, especially like, like high, like high achievement society is like, And I think social media has made this worse, like social media being LinkedIn, X, even Instagram. It's like people only share like a slice of that reality, right? Like, hey, like I'm working in the labs or I'm like this like cool founder that raised, you know, like hundreds of millions, right? But I think you don't really get to see like the other parts and the decisions that come with it and like the full package in a way. And I think a lot of times like when you have this shiny object syndrome, right? Of like, hey, like this, like it would be awesome to see like I could be one of those PMs that I can put like member of the product staff at X, right? Like X being kind of like placeholder, not the company. And that, but then it's like, yeah, like you don't really know that a lot of them are stressed as hell because they're sprinting for an IPO and they're working super hard and They're questioning whether they're building this thing that we'll regret building. So I think there's all these things that I don't think you, or maybe they're miserable because they're comparing themselves next to someone who will make $200 million when they're only making $10 million. That's tragic, right? We live in that world. It's so crazy, though. I know, but you hear it out loud. I'm like, what is going on? Yeah, it's like, it's like almost like, just like slap, slap him in the face. Like, what are you talking about? Yeah. So that was like the point I want to make. Yeah. I mean, I think The takeaway, like the pattern that you're describing is, is just like anchoring your sense of whatever success or self-worth or whatever to like kind of some competitive, like, I don't think there's a perfect comp for what like we do, right? Like, like when I think about like, who am I comparing myself to? There's no one else I'm comparing myself to right now because I think it would be intellectually dishonest to say anyone else is literally playing the same game I'm playing other than Mark and I are playing it together. Whereas every job I've had, it's like I'm in a career ladder and there's other people on my level and there's people at the next level and am I better at the people at the next level? And then you're talking about these people in other functions. Is my function more valuable than that function? I don't know. It's like all this comparison stuff that happens, which... None of which is serving the customers, none of which is like creating like shareholder value, but it's like real human psychology stuff that just comes up because we're tribal animals. And so as you were talking, Mark, I'm just like, and Annalie, I'm just like, man, like that. I'm so happy that I'm not like in that right now. And I've been there. I have. I know. And we've all been there. And I think we're all super competitive people. And I'm not saying that that part of me has died, but. I realize where it's healthy and where it becomes unhealthy for me. Yeah. One. Go ahead. I was going to shift directions. I was too. I'm curious where you want to go. Let's go with your direction. I think there's something that you were mentioning, Annalie, that I thought was interesting. You said you're just seeing a bunch of people in companies that are there for a month. And then kind of like, or like, you know, what did I get myself into? Or like, and I feel like, that is a little bit new. That's a little bit newer. Um, like, I mean, I think there's always been more rare. Yeah. Yeah. I just had a post about that this week too, Mark. Like where someone that we, someone that bought one of our guides started at one of the companies and then left that company after, um, less than three months. Um, For just a better opportunity. Whoa. Yeah. Is that different than what you're describing, Annalie? I've had that happen. Not entirely. I've seen that three times in the last six months too, by the way, with other people. Like someone signing an offer. Yeah. And someone did it before they started. So basically like sign an offer. Yeah. And like three weeks between the job because they had multiple interview rounds. Then like a week after it got another offer, then had like... Yeah. Yeah. Had to basically tell them, hey, FYI, like, never mind, I'm rescinding my offer. And then I had someone a month into the job being like, actually, this is a terrible decision. I'm out. Then someone, I think it was like two months later. And then in parallel, a lot of trends that I'm seeing is that people are Maybe it's like a kind of like a lag indicator is that people are much slower at updating their job changes in LinkedIn. And I feel part of it is like they're still shopping or they're waiting for the 90 day mark to make sure it's a good fit before they broadcast it. Oh, yeah. So I acted surprised to you, Ben, just because I wasn't expecting you to say that. But yes, I have seen that also. What were you expecting me to say? Um, just that people got there and realized it was a super churn and they quit because it sucked. I've seen that one too. Well you know, like I think, I think, I don't want to say in this case, I know it was because, uh, there was some, some pressure for the company to make a decision before, like basically this person told the company, Hey, like there's another company I'm talking to. I'd love to be able to see out that process before I make a decision. And they're like, well, we actually need you to make a decision by this date. Right. That's always a risk on their part. Bird in the hand instead of two birds in the bush kind of. So like accepted the offer. Other company dragged their feet a little longer, started the job. And then finally the other company moved fast enough to get to a point where this person felt like that was actually closer to like the level they should be at and like the responsibility and the scope and the team and the kind of like the environment felt like better. So it was nothing about that. There wasn't anything toxic or anything about the first company. It was more just like there was a better opportunity. And if you're going to do a job search every three to five years and you're going to stick with the one that's not the right one, you're potentially going to burn a few really important years in a place that is a level below where you should be. Yes, we've seen that internally too. We've been hiring more senior experience on average in the last couple of years because the market's been so competitive. But then we've also seen people come in for IC opportunities saying they're really committed and really want to do that and then get a lead position and lead really quick. And I think it's showing part of what we were talking about earlier is the fear. Just like I got to grab a job now so I can have a job in case I don't have a job, but I'm going to keep looking for a job I want. And recruiters are particularly skilled about convincing you that they want to be there because we know how it sells, you know. But I am actually looking to hire more junior people and we're building out a boot camp to train them up because it has actually been a problem. Yeah. How do you think, sorry, just like a follow-up on that, Mark, if you don't mind. Just curious, like has anything changed in how you think about kind of like retaining talent and given the market dynamics at play right now when it comes to like either your most senior talent on your team or your junior talent? Like is there anything that's changing in how you think about that? So yes, absolutely. The context being the beginning of the company, clients wanted to work directly with me and I hired mostly junior people managed by very senior people, but the very senior people were more client facing and junior people were more background. And then the Zerp era, you know, like when the market boomed and all this funding was pouring into the valley, um, We were able to get away with that for a while and scale, but it also hit capacity. We reached 2.4 million revenue and I just couldn't scale past that. It was like I was working too much. And then the market crashed pretty abruptly and there was all these waves of layoffs and all these senior recruiters entering the market that were more affordable than they had been. And so since January 2023, we've been steadily scaling the company up to 35 where almost everybody is senior. But now it's very top heavy and you want to continue to grow compensation and not everyone can be promoted to manager. And it's just like becoming this whole thing where now we want to bounce the team and do a little bit of a hybrid and reintroduce the junior profiles, but have them be more background supporting of the senior recruiters so that we can improve our margin and also just like have it be less competitive with all these senior in terms of opportunity. And I would say that the market is impacting this directly in terms of My senior recruiters can get huge offers at AI companies and I can't compete. And so you have to think about really finding the right people that are wanting to be in an agency, working with a number of startups. There are certain reasons that people would want to do that. And also just what is unique about us, for example, that we are 100% remote, whereas most of these AI companies are going to require an office if not, hybrid if not, five days a week. So just thinking about what are our differentiators, what's appealing about working here. We offer people part-time opportunities if they want to work 20 or 30 hours a week, which is really unusual. So just having to get creative about what can we offer that's different. And then also just accepting that this isn't going to be a fit for everybody if they're fully optimizing for a comp. Yeah. I mean, makes a lot of sense. And even for, I'm sure like when you train up, Junior recruiters, they will eventually fly out of the nest when one of these companies or one of the clients like comes to them. I know. I just lost my new grad. I hired her out of school and she was with us for five and a half years and she just got pushed for an insane offer. We miss her so much. I'm grieving. I'm sure you're so proud too. So proud. She's incredible. She's definitely someone I'll keep in touch with. But that is so cool, right? The fact that, you know, someone started their career with you, like it's almost like the Boulevard Mafia in a way, right? Yeah, we had two of this in the last quarter. The other one went over to SpaceX recently. Wow. So I'm just very proud. Like, I think we've built a brand that is competitive and that's really cool. Yeah. And I'm sure like the more examples you have of that, the easier it is going to be like attracting that junior time. You're like, hey, like, You do your tour of duty here for three to four years. Like look at where all these other people are going. And I will say the market trend is the junior people are more retainable because it is harder to get a job as a junior person right now. So it's almost like they have more loyalty. Well, it's just there's very rare opportunities and especially in the where we play with startups and startups have less recruiter headcount. So the expectation on that one recruiter is enormous. It's very rare that they would say, let me hire a new grad for that one, you know. So for junior people to come in and have some exposure to that and training and ability to get experience is just unique. Also just being able to learn from you if I was like an entry-level recruiter in my like whatever early 20s or something and I had to choose between going and being like one of two recruiters or something or the only recruiter in an early stage environment versus getting a chance to learn from you, right? Oh, thank you. Yeah, I think that would be like a no-brainer for like the learning process. And the experience. And I think the other thing is what I think is really great is just having the support of a team because being that one or two can be really lonely and huge. I was that person for a bit at Figma, you know, like I went in there. That's a tough job. Super tough job. Founding a recruiter is super hard. And there had been one girl in the role before me, but she had left. And then I was hired in as head of recruiting team. And yeah, I was reporting to the CEO and I was the most experienced recruiter experienced in the company. So I had to really lean on my network and try to figure out how to do things. I want to take a moment before we get back to the episode to tell you about Insider Loops. This is a company that Mark and I started because we just believe this should exist. Companies should be offering candidates the best possible preparation for their loops, yet what they give them is vague and often not very actionable. So we took the matter into our own hands. We've put together well-researched and continuously updated guides for PMs interviewing at companies like Anthropic, OpenAI, Google, Stripe, DoorDash, and more. If you're getting ready for PM interviews at those companies, go over to insiderloops.com and learn more. It's a lonely time to be a product leader. The role keeps changing. There's AI hype everywhere, and people look to you for answers. And that's why I created Supra, an invite-only community for senior product leaders and the partner of this podcast. And fun fact, I met Ben when he joined Supra. When you join, we match you with seven peers at your level and company stage. You can be honest about the problems you're facing and learn from people who've handled similar challenges in a fully confidential space. That can help you get to a solution much faster. Learn more at joinsupra.com. Now, back to the episode. Yeah, I do want to go back to the, like, why are we seeing shorter tenures? But one last data point that I'll share on, like, just junior talent in general, because I think that's, Been something that's been very top of mind for me for, I would say, the last like year and a half or two. I just like always like worried. And part of my worry was like I have a younger brother. We're like 11 years apart. So he just entered the workforce. Yeah, like two or three months ago. He's a software engineer and he's at Google. And I'm always like telling him like, listen, like I think at this point of your life, like it doesn't really matter. You shouldn't really be optimizing for money. I think you should really be optimizing for an environment where you're just going to learn the most amount. And I think it's really sad. I do think that is becoming very, very rare to find an environment where they really nourish that junior employee, especially as orgs get flatter and flatter. And that Flutter Orc gets celebrated, right? Like we see like people like Jensen Huang, like flexing that he has like 65 like direct reports or like the Revolut funder who says like he has like 51 or Alexander Wang who is like... I have one, by the way. I mean, I hear that and I'm like, that sounds like a nightmare, right? Or like Alexander Wang, he went into David Sendra and said he had 200 reports. I'm like... So, and I think the only way you can do that is if you're like either one extremely competent and extremely autonomous and just like you just like thrive in that environment that you need to be very self-directed. Like no one's going to be holding your hand and be like, here, how do you do things? Do think that, yeah, like unfortunately, people are going to be following those trends. People are going to be like, oh, like we should do like, you know, like NVIDIA is doing that or Reblus. Those are crushing, right? And there's always like this survivorship bias, which is very dangerous. But anyways, I just feel like hopefully junior talent is going to recognize that actually going to companies like yours where you take care of them, you'll train them. It's way more valuable than maybe going for these hot startups that, you know, they're going to either you swim or you sink. And if you sink, we don't really care about you. And it's really hard to get in right now. It's such a fiercely competitive market. That's a really good point. No, no, that's spot on. And going back to the short 10 years thing, I think what seems kind of maybe like useful to, in my mind, at least about that topic is kind of like if, Like, if there's something people can do about, like, if there's something people can do to either decrease the chance that they'll go into an environment that's, like, the wrong fit for them. Mark, were you going to go somewhere else for that topic? Well, I think that the first step is, like, I think there's actually, like, there's two, like, very separate, like, stories of the short tenures. I think it's important to, like, be very specific and crisp about which one are we talking about. Because I think there's the one where someone... There's one where you take the role and you're super excited about it and you think it's going to work out and then it doesn't either because you get let go and just companies. And I think just part of it is like either companies are just faster and feel more comfortable like hiring and firing. I think that's maybe one of the tales. I think the other tale is like candidates go into the market with I don't want to like, okay, fine. I'm going to say it like a little bit of like a scarcity mindset. Right. And they're like, shit, like I need to get an offer. Right. And then like, and they get nervous. They have like four or five loops happening in parallel. They haven't landed any offer in a long time. So they land the first one and they just take it because there's like that time pressure, even though like their dream job is like still has, it's like maybe two loops away from getting that offer, but they just don't have the confidence that they're going to get the offer. So they're like, They're doing like the expected value calculation. Their head is like, oh shit, like I should just, you know, don't be greedy and take what I have and I should be thankful. So I think those are like two very different. There's a three, but maybe lump it into one. That's people who are a little bit more financially stable that just burn out and just quit. So they go in and like, they're like, oh shit. Like they look around. They're just like, no, this was a crazy, this was a crazy offer, but it's requiring me to give my blood. So yeah. Um, I, I think the scenario, so yeah, like those are, I agree, those are different scenarios. I think a lot of, okay, if I were to almost like size the number of people in these scenarios, I feel like the one with like the scarcity mindset has the most people in it right now. Yeah, I agree. I would say the second one is probably the people who are, um, who are, um, Financially secure and go into a role, realize it's not a great fit and they dip out, like they basically are like, nevermind. And then I'd say probably just from what I'm seeing, and again, maybe people don't talk about it as much because it's like they feel maybe some shame about it. But like that third group, I just don't hear that many people kind of go into a role and these days in my circle and they're like, they get fired in the first three months or something. I just don't see it happen that often. It's happening though. You are seeing a lot of it? Yeah. Not a lot, but it's happening. I just had a conversation about this. But do people attribute that to just like fit or do they attribute that to performance? Like what is the thing that they tend to attribute it to? I feel people are not... Fit is the catch-all, right? Yeah. I think the reason for fit is harder to figure out. Like I think... These companies, because they make such a drastic decision, I think they let people control the narrative. But see, they're like, you're just not performing. You and your manager are not getting along. Yeah by the way I just thought of three Like really quickly thought of three that had happened recently in my network that are great people, by the way. And the causes? Yeah, I'm curious. What came to mind? So I'm under the impression going back to this fear that's going through the valley and you see leaders operating in fear and Trying to keep up with the Joneses and iterate really fast and freak out if they're not moving fast enough and firing. And, you know, it's just it could be explained for a variety of reasons, but I guess it could be performance related in their mind and they just might call it fit. But just to be clear. I don't know. I actually did just have another friend tell me that it was purely fit and their performance was great. And like they had just hired. Someone else that came in and didn't jive with them and they were gone. So I don't know. And this is like a really lovely person, by the way. So like, I mean, isn't performance like in my mind, there's always a aspect of performance that's objective. Like, you know, if you're like a salesperson, you have quotas or something like you could point to like, you know, the numbers and be like that, that performance is objectively good or whatever. Not if they've only been there for three months or less. Right. That's what I'm getting to is like, I think in the first 90 days, that type of performance, like the objective performance is very rarely, um, like the expectations are just like hard to like get to a place where someone's going to get on the scoreboard in a meaningful way in the first 90 days, unless like you, you go to the second bucket and the second bucket of performance is more about like perception. Right. So it's more of this like the narrative around how this person's doing. Like if someone joins a company and everyone's like, oh, like this person's amazing. Like I'm so excited they're here. They're moving this project forward. You don't even need to know the specifics. But if people are talking about someone that way, you're like, oh, this person's crushing it. There's like a narrative about them doing really well, even though there might not be any objective scoreboard that they've gone on. You know, it's honestly really hard to say because these situations have a lot of confidential around them. And so people aren't always even able to disclose what's happening, you know? And I think that maybe a theme, though, is like, go faster, go faster, go faster. Like, it's just demanding so much of people. And I've seen people get pushed out and I've seen them burn on and leave. So it's about culture fit? Is it culture fit? If we describe culture as almost like the combination of expectations around speed, availability, responsiveness, intensity. Honestly, in startups, I think startup culture is the founder's personality. 100%. That's what it is. And so it's like, do they butt heads with the founder? Yeah. Yeah. Which I think in a best practice scenario, you need someone who is comfortable butting heads with the founder. That is usually a gift if they're able to share their expertise. But what I'm seeing is founders just moving super fast and acting more impulsively. That's just what I'm guessing. I don't fully know. And founders were already a pretty impulsive bunch before this. Right. Everything has always been crazy. Everything has always been competitive. And so right now, it's just a little bit more of a pressure cooker. And everything's escalated. Yeah, totally. I mean, I also think, like, because the timelines are being compressed, like, I think founders are way more... Sensitive to opportunity cost, right? And like the opportunity cost of having the bad fit in the seat for two months or three months in AI time is, it could be like a fatal mistake, especially like if it's a critical person, right? Like a CRO or a head of product. And right. So like, I think, but it's probably the other thing that's happening, right? It's like, Hey, like I just, you know, we, we, we really cannot like Like we need to be firing at all cylinders and we cannot afford to waste two or three months because probably it's more, right? Like if you fire someone, then it's probably going to take like, you're probably going to be, hey, I want to be more careful about the next person I hire. So it's probably like some roles take a while. It's going to be like, okay, like you basically already lost five months, right? So like three months with the wrong person, two months before filling up that role, maybe another one to like have them fully ramp up up to speed. Or another example I just thought of, um, Was just the person wasn't adopting AI fast enough. And they're not willing to modernize. And granted, this was more a service firm, but they work with tech companies. But yeah, there's just a lot of reasons right now. And this is why I think the theme is churn. And it's really, it's been rough. And I want to go back to the having fun intention we said. That's not the most fun. I think that's an interesting question that I have, and maybe it's a trick question. Whose fault is it? Should everyone take accountability when this happens? Should the founders be... When this happens, there's such a short tenure. I don't know if like pointing fingers is necessarily where my head goes here. It's more about like if we were to like bring almost like anthropological like analysis perspective to this and just like observe it and like we're watching on National Geographic like, oh, what might be going on here? Like what? Why is this happening? Right. And I think, I think the reasons are, you know, things I suspect you won't find surprising, Mark, because we've talked about them before. But it's, I think it's, it's about both sides, probably having an element of wanting to move faster than they probably should. So like candidates wanting to accept something faster than they probably should. And hiring managers wanting to fill a role faster than they should probably. And there's probably also an element of a lack of intentionality around what they want. So like candidates probably not being as intentional about what they want and hiring managers not being as intentional about what they want. And then the third piece being about really being honest with themselves about what it would take for someone to be successful in a given role. So like the candidate not really applying the super critical lens and asking the really hard questions about whether they'll be set up for success in a role because they're eager to take something. And the hiring manager not asking themselves the hard questions about whether the person they put in the role will be set up for success given the environment they've created for them. And I think when all of those conditions add up, it's like a good fit is extremely unlikely to emerge, right? But if that level of intentionality is there and people are having a measured degree of impatience, like I like to call it, about the speed with which they move. And then also there's a lot of diligence being done on both sides to really make sure the conditions are right for someone to be successful. I think that's the environment in which I think a good fit is more likely to happen. Yeah. So, yeah, I think to summarize, it seems to like, just lack of maybe... I mean, call me out if you guys disagree. Like, this is just like, I'm riffing on this as we're talking about it. It sounds like lack of intentionality on both sides, right? And I think the thing that's really hard is that you can only control your side of the story, right? But like, if a company comes in and says, hey, like, We know who we are. We know what we want. But then the reality is something else. It's actually really hard to suss out unless you're an elite investigator and can go deep into the company, start talking to employees, be like, hey, I hear this thing. It's so hard. You need access. You need courage. Not saying it's easy. And guys, the variables keep changing. So whatever you assessed and made your decision around, like in the case of My friend who someone got hired in after her, that was not part of the equation when she was considering it. And so my message to her was like, don't lose all confidence in yourself and your ability to assess something. We are in a churning market where things are changing very rapidly. You know, like there's just things you'll never be able to anticipate. And that is life. And tech is really dramatic about that right now. I think people are being pushed to the brim of what they're comfortable with as it pertains to like Being comfortable with change and adapting with change right now across the board. And I think people that have a hard time adjusting to change are going to struggle in this environment in general. I think that's also another maybe unkind or maybe not popular thing to say, but I think there's kindness in saying the truth. And I think if you're existing in an environment of increasing speed of change, The rate of change is increasing than people who are not doing the things that they need to do to make themselves more comfortable, like becoming more of a person who kind of like thrives in change. You're by definition losing the fitness game like by Darwinian measures. So like I would say, you know, I don't think big tech is a place you can go hide it out. I don't think startups are a place you can go hide it out. I don't think starting your own company is a place you could hide it out. I don't think there's a safe place to go and chill and weather the storm while the change is happening. That's gone. I think it's just a mindset shift. Now, again, if you're down for change and you go into an environment where there's a lot of change and it's not a good fit, let's just make it at least not about you being not the kind of person that's comfortable with change. It could be a bunch of other reasons. But the example of the person not adopting AI fast enough is if I'm a hiring manager... And I'm like trying to hire someone and I really care about how they adopt AI and I didn't evaluate that in the interview process. That's like completely my fuck up as like a hiring manager. Like that should be somewhere in the interview process. Like talk to this person, like how do you use AI? Like what are you excited about? What's not good enough yet for you? Like, you know, and if people can't express like good opinions or like valid opinions about like their AI usage, like filter them out. Like they're not a good fit for you. Right. Mm hmm. So just take the things you care about and literally turn those into your interview process and just evaluate that stuff. And then don't evaluate anything that you don't think is important for someone to be successful in your company. It's ultimately that simple. Easy. But the concept has to be simple, right? The implementation can have nuance, but the concept has to be super simple. Totally. And if you're a candidate, go to a place where you can be successful, where you think you'll also meet your goals in life. That's the other, that's the candidate facing simple version of this. I mean, yeah, I mean, we see this like, because we look like at interview loops like all day. And it's, I think part of the problem is that I think people don't think from first principles when they are designing their own interview loop, right? Like they just literally like are forking an interview loop that already exists to be like, oh, like if Meta does this, They probably know a lot more than we do on Meta, right? About, sorry, assessing product managers, assessing recruiters, like, like, Like, who do we think we are to, like, kind of rethink how hiring happens, right? And I think, like, you see that, like, you can just trace all these companies and, like, there's, like, almost this, like, shared root and foundation when I think they should be way more different because they're, like, totally different companies. And I think, you know, they get a little bit to, like, when you can see the culture shine in a lot of these loops, but still, like, a lot of the Lego blocks are very consistent. And some of them, in my opinion, don't really make sense. One thing maybe just like- It looked like she had something to say, but like, go ahead, Mark. We're going to go somewhere else or follow up on that? Yeah. I was going to do something like a more fun question, like since the intention is having fun, but like fun. I took it on me. I am having fun. Just to be clear, this is fun for me. I'm having fun here. I'm having fun too, but. I think what I was just pondering was something that has surfaced in my mind recently. It's a yes, and there's always a counterpoint of maybe you have a really beautifully designed interview loop and perfectly configured requirements and preferences in your job description. And the other mess I can see, at least when it comes to STARPs, but I would imagine big tech as well, just in terms of also not being willing to take a bet on somebody. And being able to hire the person that checked eight out of the 10 things. And sometimes they just get so obsessed about the 10 things and don't take the bet. So for example, a lot of founders and recruiters will approach me to go be a founding recruiter or head of talent. I'm like, I am so past that. I get what you would approach me. I've done it. It's safe for you. But like Pigma took a huge bet on me. Palantir took a huge bet on me. I was like very junior back then and used to be an accountant. And like those companies have done very well. Taking bets on people. And so it's like, yeah, you want to try to perfectly predict if a canvas can be successful or not, but you also want a little bit of wiggle room to take a bet on people. Yeah, I do think in this in this hiring environment, in the spirit of realism, the prevailing sentiment I'm hearing from hiring managers is because there's so many great people on the market. I don't have to compromise on any of my, you know, like requirements. So like, why would I take someone who doesn't check all my boxes, right? I think some companies can do that. And still some candidates are going to say no to them, as I referenced earlier, but they can get away with it for the most part. But most AI startups are not going to be able to do that. That's such a good point. Yeah. Like, I think if you don't have, like, you know, like, Like the top 0.5%, right? They're going for brand, they're going for talent density, and they're going for insane pay. Maybe an AI startup has like the brand because they raised 100 million from Andreessen, right? But now everybody's doing that. So the metrics have changed. Well, I think what we're also talking about is like once someone is already priced at the whatever $1 million a year, like the market like wants to pay someone a million dollars a year. They're kind of like, by the way, in big tech, that might not sound like that much. But like in startup world, I think a million dollars a year is still like a lot. Yeah. For a lot of people. For the most part. And I would say by the time someone has that price point, It's almost like you've already, there's no arbitrage opportunity available on like getting them, right? Like the people that hire- Unless they're missionaries. Unless they're, but the mission, yeah, fair. But like there's not, even missionaries are going to look for the best- What do you mean by that? Like, have you heard a term of like missionary versus mercenary? No. I mean, I'm ex-Mormon, so I definitely know missionary from like that perspective and it's confusing me in this context. Yeah, maybe, yeah, in this context, it might be a little bit different. But maybe, like, there's some shades that are similar. But, like, basically, like, a mercenary is someone who is just maximizing for, like, pay, right? Like, they'll work, like, they don't, like, even if the company is doing evil, but they pay them, like, 20, like, you know, like, the extreme would be, like, hey, like, if Phil Morris, you know, the tobacco company, pays me, like, 30 million a year, like, I'll take that offer because the next one is, like, 5 million and that's fine. I get there to do a mission. I get paid. My conscience is at peace. They're a mercenary. Yeah, they're just like a mercenary. They're like a hired gun and they'll go for like whatever is like the highest value they can get for their time and their skills. Okay. Then the next one is like more of like a missionary that's like, hey, like actually like, you know, I need to get my needs met, but I need to pay my bills. But like to me, like I find I need to work for a company that I deeply believe in their mission that I think they're doing. That's me. Yeah. Like the integrity, like I want to work for people that have a lot of integrity, like that kind of thing. Yeah. That want to make the world a better place. And so in that case, right, like, let's say, like, there's, like, a Series A company that's really, like, set to, like, revolutionize cancer care and, like, really, like, and maybe doesn't have that much brand, maybe paying me $300,000 instead of a million. Like, there's some missionaries that will take that offer because it's just, like, the value, the, like, the intrinsic value that I get from, like, helping the world is more valuable than maybe the $700. And that's your average startup candidate. Totally. In this sort of market particularly. Totally, yeah. So the point I was trying to make is that by the time, I would argue, by the time even the 300,000 person comes to you, because that 300,000 person is choosing the missionary, but they could go out and be a mercenary for a million. So like the market value of their services is a million dollars, right? Yeah, may I just call out how crazy these numbers are to the average person? Non-tech person. Yeah. Although I just did see an article about how like families in San Francisco, like, you know, double, dual income household families in San Francisco that make what, what was the number? Like 350 or something are like basically just making ends meet right now. Yeah. It's wild out there for sure. So, but, but, you know, the separate topic on cost of living and all the craziness there. But like, I would say my point is when we all got our first Like breaks, like our first meaningful, you know, roles that allowed us to demonstrate what we're capable of in environments that are growing fast. The market had not priced us yet, right? Our potential was not priced into our market value. There was a lot we had to prove. But, you know, the point is like each of us had someone see something in us that had a lot of potential and they got us for what they probably considered to be a great deal. Right. And then we probably exceeded expectations on that and some time passes. And then now the market values you at whatever you're properly, you know, it's properly priced in, but then it's too, you're too expensive for that other, for another company at the same stage to have gotten you at that rate again. You're just like too expensive for them now. So my point is like, If you want to talk about first principles hiring, I think the ultimate first principles hiring to me is how do you actually find the perfect people or the best people for your job when the market has not priced them in yet? That's kind of what I'm saying. You don't find the people everyone else wants already because they're priced in. You find the people who are not priced in yet and then you get them in. Absolutely. That's hard to do. But that's a really good talent strategy, I think. If you think about hiring as any other business unit, and you're running a P&L and you're hiring, that's the way to do it. That's how soccer teams do it. They grow their own talent in-house. If soccer teams only had players who they bought from other teams once they were worth a lot of money, that would be a terrible business to run. And I think that there's a lot of pressure to speed right now, and that's why there's more pressure to find someone who's been there so this bet is less risky in their value. But then you're taking, I think a higher, the trade-off there, right? Everything has trade-offs. So like the trade-off there is that you're, I think taking on more culture fit risk because you're taking someone who comes more with like preconceived notions on how things are done and they're probably going to be more senior, which means they're more likely to be at, you know, maybe not see eye to eye with you on everything. If we're talking about the founder and head of product kind of scenario or some of their head of talent or whatever. So, you know, I think oftentimes and we've had multiple people on the podcast come and say it, but like if you're going to hire someone, Like if you're looking to hire a head of something or an executive, you hire from within because those people are already going to a good culture fit. Like that's your best bet versus bringing someone from the outside. I think the problem now is that because there's this urgency, like you don't have, like I think like betting on what I call like emerging market like bets is like, It is like, I think long-term makes a lot of sense, but I think now it's like too risky. So it's like almost like the risk of like not working out and not having someone great in the next like six months is what I think freaks people out a little bit. And I think everyone, I think that's part of the problem. Everyone's like, Thinking very much shorter, right? Of like, hey, like, how do I get, like, because they don't really know what the scoreboard or the chessboard is going to look like in a year. And I think that's true. Like, it's a reality. Like, it's so hard to know. And I think that's what's so tricky about this environment right now. It does seem to me like a pretty risky proposition, though, to say, like, I want to grow faster. Therefore, I'm going to, like, hire really fast. Like, that leap, that logical leap doesn't, Like on its surface, you'd be like, oh yeah, of course, just like hire for it. But if you're going to compromise the quality of the fit, then like the speed of the hiring will not allow you to grow faster. Yes. And there was a flip where you just don't hire anyone because you're being too picky and the startup can't do anything because no one's in the seat. Because you're bottlenecking. We see that a lot. Yeah. Founders wanting 10 out of 10 and they won't budge on the geography or the target companies or like, it's just like. What do you tell someone actually, this is actually something Mark and I might personally benefit from as far as advice goes, but what do you tell someone who feels like they, they might be thinking of like the perfect shape of a person as being too fully loaded and maybe they need to like scope it down to like the thing that's actually going to like relieve the growth bottleneck, like. How do you tell that to someone in a way that resonates? Yeah, so for me, it starts with just data of, we call it a market map. And so we will track a sample of tier one candidates that meet every criteria. We'll actually say, okay, if we were to search this one target company or three target companies or whatever it might be, in this geography, with this experience level, with this other things you said that you needed, we've got... 300 results and two of them were in the tier two category. This happens all the time, by the way. And so we say, if we were to include people that are off on one or two of the criteria, here are eight that you might consider. And what will often happen is the founders will be like, nope, don't want any of that, only want the two. And so we have to adjust expectations and say, well, if there's a short list of like 10 people in the world that you would hire for this, We've got to change your strategy and go very high touch in VIP and different engagement strategy because just a cold email from a recruiter is not going to cut it. Or we say, okay, let's start to think about splitting this job in two. Like, can we just solve for this problem and then this problem? If anything, just to move faster because there comes a point where the recruiting fees in themselves just add up, whether that's an in-house recruiter or an agency. It's just time is money. Your interviewer's time is money. Your whole team's time is money. And so it's like, yeah, it's expensive to hire two people. But like if you can't realistically hire the one person and your business needs that functioning, then maybe there's a case to split it in two. And I have seen companies do that. Yeah. Awesome. But I think, Ben, your question was more on like, was it like, So I think probably the hard thing is like people go to Annalie like when they already know they need to hire someone. But I think the hard part is convincing them like who is the right person to hire. I think your question was like even before they decided to hire someone, like what is it? Yeah. That like, hey, you might want to, you are the bottleneck. And if you don't bring someone else, like you're never going to be able to scale. Right. And I think that's maybe the question that you're trying to get at is like, you know, like. Yeah, we could probably have a whole. Like what do you say? Hour and a half conversation just about when to hire. Like, when should you hire? Or like, how do you know you should hire? Something like that. And so I don't know if we have time to open up that whole topic. But I agree with your premise, which is by the time people typically engage with recruiters, they probably have some clarity on like what they need. And there's a long... tail lead up maybe years, right? Like leading up to that reach out or like the decision I need to get, I need to hire someone that's like, I've been doing this badly. This other person on my team has been doing this badly. It's probably like we've somehow been sliding by without being good at this. And now we need to like be good at this. Or we used to be really good at this. Now the person that was really good on this left the team and we need to like find a replacement or something like that. Or you're scaling and nobody knows what to do and you need to find someone who does. Or you're not growing fast enough, right? Like your revenue has plateaued because probably there's someone at the company that's the bottleneck for everything, right? Yeah, but all these tie back to business. There's a business problem. And like these days, I'll be honest, like hiring a human is not the first place my head goes for solving business problems. Like, you know, like I'll just, It needs to be said. The agents are really good at certain things. And so it's not obvious to me which things the human will be better at than the agent. Recruiting. I agree with that. Sales. Yeah. Yeah. But, you know, marketing? I don't know. Like, I think, like, my point is, like, We need to be really intellectually honest. The goalpost is shifting faster. All of our existing beliefs about what AI is good at cannot possibly be based on what AI is good at today because we have not done all the things with AI today. So we don't know how good AI is at everything today. Our beliefs are shaped by all the things we've tried to do with AI ourselves over the last few years. And there's a lot of things that AI was not good at like a year ago that it's actually really good at today. But the only way you'll know and be able to update your mental model is if you try it again. Right. So in my mind, it's very hard to know what whether my mental model for like what humans are better at than AI is still true today across like an entire swath of jobs that I need done. But I think I want to push you a little bit there because I think. The really risky headspace there too is like, who are we to judge whether the AI is better than a human for a function that we are not experts in? For example, let's say we wanted to get better at marketing. Like why are we, why should we be the judges whether agents is good at marketing or not when we didn't know nothing about marketing, right? Yeah, I still think that it depends on a scale. If you're a small shop and a few million revenue or whatever, like maybe agents can manage most of it. But I think there is a scale where you at least need people in marketing to run the bots at this, where we are today. Agreed. We're not seeing a slowdown in hiring. Like people, it's a lot of hiring currently. And will that change? Yes. We don't know. I think I'm thinking more with the bootstrapped founder lens as I ask these questions. Yes. And like I appreciate when people try to solve the problem first before they just hire because you have to survive and be able to, you know, have profit on the horizon. Yeah. But I think it's much easier. Like I think from my personal experience of using agents is – I get the most value out of agents when, like, I put them to work into something that I'm really good at because I'm really good at articulating, like, what grade looks like and, like, creating those evals. And catching when they're wrong. Catching when they are wrong, but also, like, really being able to diagnose and improve different parts of the process, right? And, like, knowing and, like, being able to, like, Almost assess the judgment that it applies to different steps of the process, right? And you see that with writing, for example. I think a lot of people are using AI for writing. People that are better writers usually get better outputs from agents because they know more about... They know how to back-engineer the creative act of writing, right? Because they're able to feed it better context. They're able to almost... Decompose the process in a more thoughtful way. And I think that's true for probably engineers, right? Engineers get way more out of like coding agents that probably me and Ben do because they've just like know how, yeah, they just like know like where like the corpuses are hidden when it comes to big, you know, like code bases and like security and auth and those things. So, and I think that's the tricky part, right? They've gotten so good at creating, like, just anything that's believable, that's good enough. And it's sometimes really hard to discern, like, is this actually makes sense or not? And I think that's the really hard part, I think. Well, so the AI frontier companies are hiring the most. So we know that bots can't replace people. Like, until they automate everything, we're good. Yeah. Yeah. But whether a full-time person is needed versus just a human, In a bootstrap scale, you're right. No, I don't think so. I think a really good advisor plus super powered by an agent, I think that is a really underrated combination. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Which is just making me think I need to hire my friend to advise us on marketing She's amazing. Can we talk to your friend trust a bot for that. Yes! She's like Spigma. She's so good. Yeah, we might want to, we're very much, like we're not hiring full-time people, but like we're trying to kind of load up on really good advice from people and we're definitely willing to pay for that, so. And she has some ed tech background too. Cool. Yeah. Very cool. All right, I know we are probably at time to wrap up, so. This was great. I know we kind of wandered around a little bit, but I think that's actually, that's the messiness, the market's messy right now. And I think this conversation and like the places we went reflect it. And I think that feels accurate. I wanted to ask you two questions, Annalie, and then Mark can do our special gratitude corner. So if the audience wants to learn more about what you are thinking about these days and follow you, where would you have them go to follow you? And then also, how can they potentially be helpful to you? So I'm really only on one platform. That's LinkedIn. And I am so up and down with it. Like I'm trying to be more consistent because it does bring a lot of value to our company when I post. But that's where you would find me. And then I would encourage you and a way to help me would be just follow my company page, Boulevard Recruiting. It's very cute. My team rotates posting every week. So it's a new individual every week. So it's a little bit disjointed in like the tone and like the voice because it's a lot of people. But I think it's pretty fun and it's always fun to support them. Amazing. We'll link your profile on the company page, the show notes. And that's actually a cool, really cool, like almost like team building activity of like having rotating like hot potato writing on the company page. That's awesome. Yeah, it's really funny. I get I have so much joy when I read it every week. Do you know who is posting or is it like kind of like, okay. Yeah, for sure. We have one person reviewing and she's the one that's like rotating the seat across different people. But I can see because we're talking about it internally and when it goes live. Nice. Because that could be a fun game and be like, oh, who wrote that? Who is that? But I am starting to see different voices and detect them before I see it in Slack. Nice. Awesome. And then our final question, which is Gratitude Corner. And yeah, you've had such an awesome journey and Canon, Palantir, Figma, now building this really, really cool like recruiting firm. And that's helping so many startups. So we just wanted to take a moment to, yeah, to just give you the opportunity to thank maybe one or two or three people that have played a key role in your journey so far. Oh, it's 100% my parents. And I don't want to cry. It makes me want to cry when I think about it. They're wonderful people and really empowered me since I was very young and always told me I can do anything, like maybe irrationally. Like saying the only difference between you and a CEO is experience to go learn from them. And I've always been very bold in interacting with people and taking bets on myself and just supporting me in this journey of entrepreneurship. When I went to recruiting 100% commission before Palantir, Palantir was my client back then, my dad was just like, I was so scared to take commission after a stable career in accounting. And he was like, if anyone can do it, why not you? Of course you can. And I feel like that energy has really served me and I appreciate that so much. Amazing. It makes me excited to be a parent and be able to push that into the world. Yeah, that's exactly what I want from my kiddos. That's what I want from my kiddos. I just want my daughter to believe me when I tell her that. I want to be able to get through and make her truly feel when I tell that to her. Good on your dad for doing it in a way. And both your parents sounds like that got through. They're not just saying that because they're my parents, but it feels real. Well, because it would be things like I want to start a dance studio. And they were like, all right, you can use our house. And my mom's going to write the newsletter. And I don't know, like they just always, I think there were times where other parents would be like, what are you talking about? And they were just like, okay, cool. You know? Yeah, backing it up with action is the best way to, it's the best way to show what you feel is just to do things. So it's awesome that they put their money where their mouth was all along the way. And I'm not surprised that they bet on you. I mean, you're awesome at what you do. We're lucky to have you as a friend and someone to kind of like to chew on things with. And I really appreciate you taking the time. And I know our audience always gets a lot of value from you kind of sharing what you're seeing. Oh, thank you guys. Right back at you. Thank you. Very grateful to be in this journey with you both. Well, cool. That is a wrap. Bye-bye. See you soon. Bye-bye. [music]