Overview
Bruce Daisley talks with Jan-Emmanuel De Neve, an Oxford economics professor who directs the university's Wellbeing Research Centre and edits the World Happiness Report. They discuss his book Why Workplace Wellbeing Matters and the evidence that how people feel at work affects company performance. They also cover hybrid work, shared lunches, and what AI-driven layoffs do to the people who keep their jobs.
Key Takeaways
De Neve separates wellbeing into two parts. One is affective: the day-to-day experience of joy, stress, or worry. The other is evaluative: how satisfied you are when you step back and judge your job or life. The two can diverge. UK National Health Service (NHS) staff and teachers report high stress but also strong pride and purpose. He considers "wellness" a narrower, mostly physical idea and dislikes it being confused with wellbeing.
The decline in wellbeing is real but uneven. It is sharpest in English-speaking countries, while Central and Eastern Europe have seen gains, especially among young people. De Neve argues that young people in the West are already at midlife-crisis levels of wellbeing. He says somewhere between 40 and 50 percent of Americans report daily worry.
Stress behaves differently from other measures. Some is healthy. He puts the optimal level at roughly 1.5 to 2 on a five-point scale, and says most workers rate themselves well above that.
His business case rests on three pathways. The first is productivity. In his British Telecom (BT) call-center study, he reports that a one-standard-deviation improvement in mood went with about 12 percent higher weekly sales. He calls that a lower bound, since the effect was larger for emotionally demanding tasks, which are the ones AI is least likely to take over. The second is retention. The third is attracting talent. A collaborator randomized 24 million job seekers on Indeed, and those shown that a company had happy staff were more likely to apply. De Neve also links higher wellbeing to better financial results and stock returns.
Across his Indeed dataset of what he says is over 30 million workers, social connection and belonging rank as the strongest driver of how people feel at work, ahead of pay and flexibility. He reports that eating alone in the US rose by about 50 percent between 2003 and 2023, and nearly doubled among young people, mostly because people skip shared lunches.
On AI, he argues that cutting staff damages the roughly 90 percent who remain. They worry about their own jobs, resist adopting the tools, and produce "workslop," which is polished but useless AI output that ends up on the desks of the executives who ordered the cuts. Removing junior roles also empties the pipeline for future leaders.
Practical Steps
- Add four questions to regular pulse surveys: job satisfaction, happiness at work, stress level, and sense of purpose. Treat them as key performance indicators (KPIs).
- Coordinate office days across teams, two or three a week. Save those days for brainstorming, client work, and learning together, and leave report writing and email for home.
- Provide free lunch on the anchor days. Consider Oxford-style seating where people take the next open seat and phones stay away.
- Keep lunch free of meetings. Daisley's point is that if back-to-back calls fill the morning, people will want to hide at midday instead of socializing.
- Before cutting jobs for AI savings, think about the effect on the staff who stay. Train people properly and treat augmentation as the default.
- Watch whether wellbeing scores move after AI rollouts. De Neve says they show whether you are augmenting people or automating them away.
Notable Quotes
"Measure what you treasure." - Jan-Emmanuel De Neve
"You don't leave what happens at the job behind at 5 p.m. as you check out, and you don't leave life behind once you check in at 9 a.m. in the morning." - Jan-Emmanuel De Neve
"Youth today is experiencing their midlife crisis today." - Jan-Emmanuel De Neve
Full Transcript
Running a small business means wearing a lot of hats. Between managing employees, handling payroll, and keeping up with paperwork, there's a lot to juggle. Luckily, Gusto makes it easier. Gusto is online payroll and benefits software built for small businesses. It's all-in-one, remote-friendly, and incredibly easy to use, so you can pay, hire, onboard, and support your team from anywhere. From automatic payroll tax filing to simple direct deposits and benefits options for nearly every budget, Gusto helps simplify the process. Plus, enjoy unlimited payroll runs for one monthly price, with no hidden fees or surprises. And with automated tools for onboarding and offer letters, you can focus on what matters most. Try Gusto today at gusto.com/tech and get three months free when you run your first payroll. That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com/tech. One more time, gusto.com/tech. Cash now, more later. From OpenDoor gives you cash upfront for your home, plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later. Skip the showings now, pocket extra profit later. This is so simple now. This is so awesome later. Or sell fast now and pop the champagne later. Cash now, more later. Now available nationwide. Start your offer at opendoor.com/acast. Profits calculated after fees and costs. Eligibility and offer price may vary. This is Eat Sleep Work Repeat. It's a podcast about workplace culture. Hello, I'm Bruce Daisley. There's an issue that we constantly return to with conversations about workplace culture. It's the fundamental question of, does it matter? Does having happy workers correlate with better business success? Even to some extent, people look at wretchedly unhappy workers of very successful firms, and they say, Well, look. They're not happy, and that firm's really successful. Why should we waste time on trying to create a positive, benign culture for our organisation? And that's what today's guest has spent his career researching. I first saw the work of Jan-Emmanuel De Neve about 10 years ago when he did a really intriguing piece of work looking at the employees of British Telecom. British Telecom gave him access to a huge number of their employees, tracking how happy they were doing their job and the results they achieved. And the headlines that came from that piece of work were that happy, motivated workers were about 12% more successful than the average, more productive than the average, and strongly more productive than people who weren't happy, who weren't motivated in their jobs. Now, that was the first data point that I think has helped us prove what a lot of us felt instinctively, that happy workers do better work. You know, it's the underpinning of the Gallup Workplace Survey that, of course, still now finds today that 10% of British workers are engaged with their job, 8% of Italian workers are engaged with their job, that the engagement numbers are so low. So chatting to the man responsible for that, Jan-Emmanuel, was really important to me. He's a professor of economics and behavioural science at Oxford Saïd Business School, and he leads the university's Wellbeing Research Centre. He's also the editor of the World Happiness Report, the annual study that tracks how content the world's nations are. He's written extensively about the topic. His latest book, Why Workplace Wellbeing Matters, was my guide for today's conversation. It's a comprehensive analysis drawing on data from more than 20 million workers, and the scale of that means it's one of the biggest pictures we've ever had for how people actually feel about their jobs. If you've come here and you're listening to this podcast, then the evidence that Jan-Emmanuel brings is exactly what you've been looking for. I've linked to some of it in the show notes. I think you're going to find it a valuable set of proof points to take to a board-level conversation. Here's my conversation with Jan-Emmanuel De Neve. Yan Emmanuel, I wonder if, to kick off, you could introduce who you are and what you do. Yes, of course. Thank you for having me. Jan-Emmanuel De Neve, professor of economics and behavioral science at the Saïd Business School and director of the Wellbeing Research Centre. And I've been working for a little while on workplace wellbeing and the links to performance and much more. And we've published a book recently, last year, with Harvard Business Press called Why Workplace Wellbeing Matters. Could you just sort of give us an introduction into the Wellbeing Research Centre? How did it come about? What's the work that you do there? Thank you for asking. So it was founded in 2019, obviously building on my research and network that had started almost a decade earlier on what in the field we would call subjective wellbeing, just how people feel. And obviously, in the context of this podcast, it's about how people feel at work or about their work. But really, in the context much larger, it's about how people feel about how their lives are going. So the key, the workhorse measure there is life satisfaction. And you should know, and thank you for asking, the Wellbeing Research Centre is now also the host, since four years ago, of the World Happiness Report, which we produce. And that's obviously a big editorial team that's working on this and a huge, huge undertaking each year. And so within the Wellbeing Research Centre, my personal focus obviously is workplace wellbeing, being based at a business school and some of the team. But there's also a whole chunk of the team led by my deputy director, Dr. Laura Taylor, who work on child and adolescent wellbeing in the context of schools. And there's big partnerships with the International Baccalaureate Organization and the LEGO Foundation. And so our Wellbeing Research Centre has really become sort of a research group centre of about... Twelve, fifteen people and a whole network of scholars on well-being and on mostly empirical science of well-being. But we've become quite influential and quite important, I think, in this particular field. And I'm so proud of the fact that we've become a real hub for junior scholars and driving their careers. Can you help me understand a few things specifically? What do you see the differences are between well-being, wellness, and happiness? I wonder if you could just help me understand the way that you see the definitions of these things in different... So I think well-being is the more, the larger aggregate sort of indicator, if you will. And then well-being, in our world, subjective well-being is how we feel about life more generally. And that can then be broken down in either a more evaluative or more affective approach. And the affective approach is more sort of emotions, the experience of life as you go through it. And that's where happiness comes in. Both positive emotions, happy, joy, or negative emotions, or hopefully the absence thereof, of anger and stress and worry. And so we consider both affective well-being as one key sort of dimension of underpinning well-being. And then the other is more evaluative or cognitive, which is the likes of life satisfaction or job satisfaction, which have you pause for a second and reflect on more sort of the broader narrative or how things are going more generally. So not necessarily the experience of life or work as you go through it, but rather the reflection and the narrative around it more generally. And both are important. They typically go hand in hand. If the day-to-day experience on the job is great, then likely you think highly of the job more generally. But it doesn't always match one for one. And I'll give you a quick example. Here in the UK, the National Health Services, we find, for example, that people report high stress and are not happy at work most of the time. But at the same time, they're quite proud and feel purposeful, and they're proud and satisfied and find purpose in the work they're doing. Same thing for teachers. And so there's sometimes a bit of a disconnect between the experience of life and the experience of a job and how we reflect and evaluate it once taking a step back. And there's an element there I'll never forget. There's a, I think it's the opening passage of my colleague's book, Paul Dolan has a book, Happier Ever After. And so he has this opening story where he was chatting over dinner with an old friend of his who works for a big media organization. And the whole dinner, she is expressing her discontent with the day-to-day experience and bitching and moaning, in his language, about the job. And then without the slightest hesitation, stands up at the end of dinner and says, But I do love my job at the BBC. And so that's a good example of a disconnect between the day-to-day affective experience on the job. Versus how you sort of cognitively evaluate it when you take a step back. And I think it's hence his work around narratives. We tell ourselves narratives about our lives that are influenced, and the way we evaluate our jobs or our lives more generally is in the context of the social comparison or narratives we build around our own lives, because I've always wanted to be a great journalist and work for the BBC, and so now I'm here. And that's quite separate from essentially the day-to-day experience. Hence it's important. So I went away on a long, long tangent, but all this to say that I think wellbeing, especially subjective wellbeing, is sort of an umbrella notion, and underneath that you can think about sort of contentment, life evaluations, purpose as sort of the more evaluative components. And then you have the more affective components that include happiness, lower case h, and stress and sort of affect. And so that's how we tend to sort of split up these notions. Now, you did also mention wellness, and here I think this is quite separate. So, and I always, I don't like at all when people confusingly will say, Oh, you run the Wellness Research Center, and I always get sort of my skin, I have a knee-jerk reaction because not at all. Wellbeing is essentially state of mind, how we feel more generally, either affective or evaluative, pick your favorite, but, or ideally combined. Whereas wellness has a more physical connotation to it. So when you think wellness, you think sort of physical activities, yoga, or indeed potentially more working on the mind through, say, mindfulness apps and the like. But it's sort of much more limited in scope. Whereas when I think wellbeing, how life is going, I'm also thinking about the strength and the richness of your social lives. I think about whether you're paid fairly for the work you do, et cetera, et cetera. So it's a much broader concept. And so I think it's important to really strongly distinguish between the two. And I wonder if you could give us a state of where we are right now. So in your book, I think you highlight that stress at work has been going up pretty continuously for sort of the most recent period. I saw the recent World Happiness Report highlighted a big drop in wellbeing among younger people. It seems in aggregate that we're reaching a less... Happy or less well-being rich time. Is that right? Is that a fair conclusion? It is, but it's not universal. So there's also some hope here. So the trends that you're describing are very true, both in workplaces and generally in life for the Western world, and particularly for the English-speaking world. So the U.S., the U.K., Canada, Australia, New Zealand, they're the ones where these trends are most pronounced, but obviously Western Europe as well. They're not necessarily the case, and this is where obviously our World Happiness Report comes in quite strongly. For example, Central Eastern Europe has actually seen rises in well-being, and particularly so for youth. And then luckily in the Global South, there's also examples of places where we see increases. I think generally you can speak of a bit of a global convergence to some extent, where the Western world, who've always been, started at a higher level of well-being and income, and the well-being there is sadly coming down a bit, but gradually and consistently over the past decade or so. Whereas in the Global South, and especially Central and Eastern Europe, you actually see it ticking up, but starting or having started from a lower level. So there's sort of a convergence happening in terms of both income and well-being, actually, which I find quite interesting. But to your point, absolutely. If we think about the workplace, which is what the audience is perhaps most interested in, we see a gradual decline in workplace well-being. As you just mentioned stress, but we find it in job satisfaction and the other items that we can pick up and proxy for workplace well-being. A gradual decline in the Western world, and that's been going on in at least our crowdsourced data since 2020, and in other data sets since before. Is there a way for us to understand that? I was really intrigued when I was reading through some of your data, and the stress... To some extent, is not incompatible with job satisfaction. I saw you saying that actually too little stress at work actually produces a really dissatisfying job. There's a balance. I think you said two out of five stress is like a good sort of Goldilocks zone of where to be. And I also saw that women are more stressed, but women also have higher job satisfaction. So it seems like we don't want this zone where there's no stress at all. But could you help us understand then why these trends in the Western world, why we're seeing our jobs being less sort of well-being for us then? You make some interesting and good points. So first of all, yes, there is, unlike the other sort of dimensions of well-being that we capture, like job satisfaction, happiness, and purpose, that are sort of linear: the more, the better. That's not the case for stress. So the less stress is not necessarily the better. However, as you note rightly, when you look at that graph around stress, the optimal, quote-unquote, stress level is not sort of a high levels of stress. It's sort of more like a one and a half to two on a scale from one to five. And so most people would tend to rate their stress levels higher than that. And so the Goldilocks zone is certainly there, but most people are beyond that, and increasingly so. In fact, you might be interested, when people talk about stress in the scientific literature, there's this optimization, the fact that no stress is not necessarily a good thing. It's probably reflective of being bored more than anything else. There's actually language for this scale. They talk about distress when it's very high negative stress, and they talk about eustress, EU stress, if it's positive stress. And so, probably coming from the old Greek word and related to eudaimonia, which is meant to be positive. Anyway, so yes, there's definitely sort of different levels. Anyway, same thing as you rightly pointed out between for women. This is standard. We actually have a paper called sort of the gender paradox on this, where women rate the quality of their lives higher from the cognitive evaluative front, but at the same time they're more stressed. And so, we find and pick this up in the workplace as well, as you rightly note. So women, I would argue, are perhaps more passionate, and so they express at least in surveys higher levels of emotional change as men do. And then there's probably on the contentment side, that's probably a much more sort of more historic explanation there, and sort of relative to their mothers or grandmothers, I presume. But to the point you finished on, there sadly is that increase in a decrease in well-being and an increase in stress more generally. This is both in the workplace, but also more generally in life. And so I think the most worrying, no pun intended, trend is worry in the United States. So Gallup, thanks to the Gallup World Poll, the biggest rises in this negative stress, worry, anger, and specifically the measure for worry is rising dramatically in the United States, I think is now. I believe it's somewhere between 40 to 50 percent of the American population experiences worry on a day-to-day basis. And so obviously begs the question why. We need to really, I mean, come to terms with the fact that youth these days, there's a lot of worry, and deservedly so, sadly. The future of work is very unclear. Their education system doesn't necessarily prepare them well for it. The education system is outrageously expensive. Most people go into debt to get an education that may not necessarily be fit for purpose for the future of work that they are landing into. Cost of living more generally, getting onto the real estate ladder is quasi impossible for most. And so it's become really difficult, that and social media being an attack on their senses. And so it's really, it is a difficult time for youth, and we pick it up in the data, both with negative emotions as well as a general drop in the sense of contentment. I was in the American newspapers last year when we published the World Happiness Report chapter that you referred to by saying that essentially youth today is experiencing their midlife crisis today, which then begs the question, where will they be when the actual midlife crisis hits, when the real pressures of life of young kids, mortgages, aging parents, etc., actually kicks in, also the height of sort of professional responsibilities when you're sort of like early 40s to late 40s. So I'm worried about youth if they're already at the level of the midlife crisis in terms of well-being today at the age of 20-something, then where will they be when they're 45? So that should really be top of mind, I think, for everyone: managers, politicians, all of us. When we're thinking about the world of work then, so to center on that, probably one of the things that a lot of people have seen because of the longevity of the work is the Gallup Global Workforce Report, which looks at engagement. And when you're looking at your data then, because your data seems to be adjacent, and I'd love to draw comparisons, how do you see your work or the data that you pull in relation to that? I saw in your data that about a quarter of workers said that they were happy at work, and does that align onto what Gallup's reporting, or how would you differentiate the two? No, good. Thank you, Bruce. First of all, the point you raise around our data. So it's the crowdsourced data, thanks to Indeed, the world's largest job search platform. And we've been crowdsourcing with them globally across about 20-odd markets since 2019. And what we find there is, first of all, it's the world's largest study and dataset at this point. There's over 30 million workers who've responded to questions around how they feel and why and which organizations they're part of. So it's huge. And there we find that only about a quarter of people respond four or five out of five in terms of these workplace well-being items. And so that means there's a lot of room for improvement, and the trend is negative, as we've already pointed to. And that sort of mirrors, I think, it echoes what our friends at Gallup have always shown, and for a longer period in their sort of engagement indices, where they find that only about a third are thriving, or I don't know the numbers exactly, but it's always quite disconcerting to see the number of people who are actively engaged at work is actually quite small. We need to come to terms with the reality that maybe it's impossible to have everybody actively engaged at work or happy at work. There is a transactional element. Most people don't necessarily see their identity come through work or find all their meaning and purpose in life through work, and luckily so. There's a lot too life outside of work, and despite what some might want us to do. But it's also sad. There's a real opportunity because we spend so much time at work that if work is not a happy place and people aren't actively engaged, as we find in the Gallup data, then it's a real missed opportunity because job satisfaction underpins life satisfaction. How we feel at work is critical to how we feel throughout life. You sort of don't leave life, or you don't leave what happens at the job behind at 5 p.m. as you check out, and you don't leave life behind once you check in at 9 a.m. in the morning. And so these two are very much intertwined, and there's consequences from one onto the other. And so the fact that there's much room for improvement on both engagement statistics and well-being statistics in the workplace should really be a call for all to try and move the needle on that front. And even though it might be impossible to get to 100%, we should definitely be getting much higher than only 25% being happy and only, what is it, 20% being actively engaged. Could you make the case for us, the sort of the employer's case for having happy or high well-being employees? Employees. I remember seeing some of your, and I cite this quite often, the British Telecom work that you did about workers feeling happy at work and the impact that had on productivity. But it's pretty evident from what I've read is that you've evolved that argument since. And I wonder if you could make the business case for focusing on high well-being at work or high happiness at work. Oh yes, Bruce. How much time do we have? There's a lot here, but I'll try and summarize it and get straight to the point. Although, before that caveating, we should be caring for workplace well-being in its own right. I mean, the idea that we should just be squeezing people like lemons as much as we can is, yeah, it's just not who we are as human beings, or not ought to be as human beings. But if it doesn't come natural to senior managers or executives or their boards to care for human well-being, then there is a business case. And that, as you rightly point out, has really been the focus of my work over the last 10, 15 years. And the biggest first piece that came out is the one that you're referring to, BT, British Telecom, where we showed, and I think I'm very proud, frankly, to be able to say, the first causal field evidence for the link between how we feel and how we perform. It took us seven, eight years to nail causal inference, but thanks to the collaboration with BT, we essentially pulsed all their call center employees every week for a whole period, asking them how they felt this week. And then we're able to link that to very granular levels of performance, customer satisfaction, weekly sales, you name it, from seconds per call, all of it. And what we find is essentially if people are feeling better in the office, one from one week to another, it makes a meaningful difference to weekly sales, which was sort of the ultimate KPI here from a business perspective. And if you want a number, it was sort of like one standard deviation change in how people feel with a 12% increase in weekly sales. And that's, frankly, that's a lower bound estimate. And because some of these... Activities require basic, and as soon as it was more demanding types of tasks that require social-emotional intelligence, the link with how you felt onto how you perform was much higher. And so in this day and age, because this study was almost a good 10 years ago now, by now the most mundane tasks, the order-taking tasks, have been taken over by AI and machines. And so it's the tasks that are more socially and emotionally demanding are the ones where how you feel in the first place matters, drives the link to performance. And so anyway, that's the 12% is very much a lower-bound estimate of the actual impact of well-being on how we perform. But that was really the starting point, as you say, for us, because when you think about how the ways in which how we feel at work can actually impact the bottom line, there's three pathways. And the first one is that productivity/performance angle that we just discussed. So how you feel impacts how well you work. But that's only one of three pathways. The other pathway could well be, and is shown to be, retention. So if you feel good at work, Bruce, then you're more likely to stay at work. So your employer retains talent longer if they're a good place to work. And that's not just a good thing to retain your talent for longer, but it also is cost savings, because it means you're not going to have to go out in the market and recruiting new people to replace the talent you've lost and then dragging them up onto the learning curve a much more. So there's real cost savings there too. And then the third pathway to superior performance is talent attraction. That's not something that most senior managers think about. But it's really, really important. So if you are a good workplace and people are happy at work at XYZ company, then word gets out in the street, or if it doesn't get out in the street, it'll be on Glassdoor and so on and so forth. So what we've been able to show causally—in fact, it was my erstwhile student and now collaborator, George Ward, who did this for his PhD at MIT—he was able to, sit tighters, randomize 24 million job seekers into either seeing information about whether this workplace they were considering applying to, whether that is actually a good workplace according to their workers through crowdsourced data, or see no data, just normal data around pay, what the company does, how many people are working for it, the name of the CEO, what have you. So business as usual, or seeing an additional layer of data around how people feel at that place. Guess what happens? When a workplace is a good workplace, above average or high, people were more likely to put in their job applications. And so that's really impactful because it's long term. It's not going to be immediate. But if you're a good workplace, you'll start attracting better talent to begin with, more talent. And so that will pay off dividends. That will pay dividends over time. It may not be tomorrow, but it'll be in a year or two years or five years, you'll have a better workforce that's going to be more fit, that will drive your company's performance down the line. These pathways to performance: productivity, retention, recruitment, talent attraction. becoming an employer of choice. Those three are really important. And then they feed into the bottom line. And then sort of the crown, the jewel in our crown then was to be able to show that, yes, that's true. So workplaces with higher levels of workplace well-being will achieve these synergies and these pathways to performance. And what we then found is that companies with higher workplace well-being, that was correlated with these organizations doing better in terms of financial performance and even outperforming the stock market in subsequent periods. So there's something to this thesis that a good workplace is a better workplace, and markets are a bit slow to pick up on this. Or alternatively, you could argue that these pathways take their time to really feed into the bottom line. Can I ask a question? Because when I was reading through that research, the one thing that struck me was that the productivity gain appeared to come from relational energy. That when people were in a— forgive me, this is a non-academic person reading that paper— but it seemed to be that when people were in a better frame of mind, a happier state of mind, to some extent even the introverts amongst them might be marginally more extroverted, more connected. And it seemed to come from the benefit of stronger relational energy, from being in a sort of positive affect, a good mood. Is that right? And if that is the case, how would an era of hybrid working or distributed working have an impact on that relational energy? Oh God, Bruce, this is an excellent question, and there's two elements to it. First one is yes. The way we've always framed it is that feeling good helps you activate your social and emotional intelligence. And so my first instinct was, well, social is one element, but even—you're right—emotional intelligence is your EQ, is how you connect with others again. And so think about this for a second. Like, if you're a BT call center employee and you're not in a good place, you're thinking about, you have your own worries, then it's very difficult to really connect with the other person on the line and look and consider their challenges, their worries, and try and have, you know, creative solutions to it or connect with them on an emotional level. Whereas if you are feeling good, life is going all right for you, then you'll have, you'll be in the mental mind, the mindset to be able to connect socially, emotionally with others. And so it's quite natural. The more you think about this, the more this completely makes sense. You make a strong argument for something else, which is not only is it important, like how you feel to be able to unleash your social emotional intelligence and thus do better with clients, but we've also found over and over that amongst the drivers of workplace well-being, so now shifting tack a little bit. is when we look at what actually explains how people feel or why people feel the way they do, then we find over and over again that people underestimate the importance of social capital, social aspects in the workspace. So not dealing with customers, but just on the workspace itself. Having friends at work, feeling like the organization cares about you, that sense of belonging is absolutely critical to how you feel at work. In fact, it's the most critical, even more important than pay, even more important than flexibility across data sets and across time and across countries. And so that's really, really important. And it's particularly important in relationship to what you just noted, which is in this era of increasingly decentralized work, working from home, we sort of undermine, to some extent, the social relationships that we build at work. And that's a real worry. So the future of work looks bright for some drivers, so it gives us more flexibility. People might, you know, be able to work remotely. It avoids congestion and traffic and what have you. But it potentially undermines, and it is undermining in many cases, our social connection at work and that sense of belonging. And I think that will really come to haunt us in the mid to longer term. However, I do think we can find the right balance. And so if you look at working remotely, well, there's sort of two ways. It's either fully remote or partially remote, the hybrid. And I do think that we can have the best of both worlds. I do think a smart hybrid or coordinated hybrid way of working is arguably going to give us both the wins around the flexibility part and not having to commute into work every day, while also still being able to maintain our social relationships and the routines. And there's some evidence that we don't need to be in the office five days out of five in order to have the sort of the social capital and generate that sense of belonging. We can do with less. It could be two or three days. But importantly, there needs to be those two, three days in the office. You should not be sitting in some corner of the office doing Teams calls again. This would then have to be more focused on social interaction. So I think the ideal world is one where we do a smart hybrid, where we spend two, three days in the office, one or two days at home. We do the tasks that don't need others: report writing, emailing, that we do at home. Whereas anything that requires, like, synchronous interaction with other people, interaction with clients, brainstorming, learning together, seminars, that we then focus in on. When we're in the office, we actually take advantage of being together to do things that need sort of coming together as teams. Reading through your stuff, there's another word directly related to that. I've never heard this word, actually, which surprised me, which commensality, the idea of the importance of eating lunch alongside other people. I wonder if... If, Millie, that was one of the focuses of spending time in an office together, you know, just making sure we took lunch together. I wonder if you could sort of remind us of the evidence for these shared eating environments. It sort of seems obvious, but astonishingly effective. Exactly. You're smiling, and it sounds mundane, but my God, is it important to us and effective. And so, yes, it builds nicely on what we were just talking about around the importance of building social capital and feeling like you belong. And so two years ago, we came across data in the Gallup World Poll that captures, engages how many of their lunches and dinners are shared with others, obviously in the context of work, we're mostly thinking lunches. And sadly, and we have longitudinal data in the United States for the past 20 years, you're not going to believe this. In the United States, from 2003 to 2023, there's been an increase of 50%, and for youth almost a doubling, in eating alone. And when we look at it, it's mostly through, mostly the lunches have taken a hit. And when you think about this, this is obviously mostly in the context of work. And so there's been a trend over the last two decades in the English-speaking world, especially the United States, but presumably some of the UK as well, where people have moved away from lunching together to essentially go grab their sandwich somewhere, go back behind their screens, do a bit of social media, presumably, or some other errands, and that's your lunch. And so that's really, really sad and undermines, again, that piece of generating belonging. In fact, if you want numbers on this, so the Gallup data, which was funded by the organization called Ajinomoto, a big Japanese group that does fantastic work on trying to... improve well-being through food. They funded this module, and the question was asking, how many of your lunches over the past week were shared with somebody else? And so I think it's less than half at this point in the UK and the US are actually shared lunches. And so here is an opportunity for, I think, the world of work to try and generate a sense of belonging, especially on the days that people come in. So if you can coordinate amongst teams the days that people come in, well, in that case, don't go off after your sandwich and eat by yourselves. Those are the two, three days that you're in the office. I'll make those count and have people then share lunches together, presumably by offering lunch in the first place. But that's really effective, I think, in generating belonging. And maybe, frankly, here again, this hybrid working, this hybrid approach, because people will only come into the office, say, two, three days a week, it may even be expensive for organizations to offer lunch every day of the week. But if you say, okay, we're going to be offering lunch free and in the office, say on Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays, the moments that you're trying to incentivize people to come in and coordinate on, then it might help incentivize people to actually do this and come in on those particular days and then share lunch together. It's been remarkably helpful. Now, obviously, I have a good example here. I've seen it at my college at the University of Oxford, where we have lunch together every day, and this has been going on in some colleges for hundreds of years. There's a no phone policy. It doesn't even—we all know. We sit at an next available place at the high table. So we just come along between 12:30 and 1, and wherever the next available seat is, we sit down. There's this wonderful lunch that's available for us, and you chat with some of your colleagues, and you don't know whom you'll be chatting to, and it's always an interesting conversation. But— I would add, it's also very, not just the right thing to do, it's also very clever because I find we save a number of emails this way. Sure enough, on the way in or the way out, I'll be meeting with a colleague or the bursar of college or the administrator, and we can quickly resolve in a conversation of literally 10 seconds one or two issues that would otherwise require an email and setting up a time to meet. And so it's really, really clever to do this on all fronts. It's interesting, isn't it, to wonder why that is not necessarily especially common or dying out. I think, you know, one of the things you talked about is work intensification and, like, the demands of work. But as work has become more intensified and a morning that leads up to a lunch might have involved three or four meetings, it might have involved constant sense of being in a performative meeting mode, that it's perhaps understandable that sometimes people get to lunch and they just want to retreat into their cave. Or, you know, they just don't want to be surrounded with more people, want some sort of time to catch up on emails. And it just reminds you that some of the problems with work are about work design, intentional work design, thinking systemically about the way we're doing work, not allowing everything to become a meeting, exactly as to the point you've mentioned there. It just demonstrates that sometimes there does need to be, to me, a bit of design or a bit of system thinking where we just don't allow the first person with a calendar invite to determine what our working day, our working week looks like. These are really good points, and they do put a caveat to what I said just before. You're probably right. If you work in an open-plan office and throughout the nine to noon, you're already doing nothing but sort of interacting and seeing each other, then people may want a bit of private space over lunch. Whereas the academics here, it's sort of the opposite. We've retreated to our offices, obviously from nine to noon, or noon thirty in our case, and so we're kind of keen to socialize for the half hour of lunch. But I do think it's sort of not as binary, and I do think there's probably more merit than drawbacks to offering lunch together. Obviously the discussions then, especially if it's sort of meeting with other people and that's sort of like sit-at-the-next-available-spot. type of element. It does then also allow you to sort of meet with other people that are not perhaps part of your team, and it's not meant to be speaking about work. You typically speak about life. I think it will still work. But to your larger point, job design, hugely important, needless to say, on all fronts, both the fit, like, yeah, everything around job design, both the working hours, the flexibility on that front, even the desk, the greenery around you, exposure to light, lunches, no lunches, how those are structured, peer recognition schemes or not, incentivized them or not. All of it is job design and can make a huge difference. Could we just go on, we're sort of coming to the end, but can we just go on and talk briefly about AI automation, the impact that it's going to have on our sense of, I guess, security with work against the satisfaction? One of the things I saw along the way in your research was that job cuts not only impact the people in work, but have this sort of contagion that when people have seen their colleagues lose their jobs, their own job anxiety and insecurity goes up, and so it makes their own job less satisfying and less rewarding. And that, to some extent, feels to be the climate of the debate about AI job displacement. I just wonder how you're perceiving the next five years in terms of AI and jobs. Well, I think, Bruce, thank you for raising this, and thank you for reading all of our material and recent research. The piece that you're referring to is, we published it in April in the Harvard Business Review, and it essentially is, I lay out the case that there's two paths that organizations can take. One is augmentation, one is automation. And while senior leaders are somehow compulsively pulled in the direction of automating... People out of jobs and to generate cost savings and bottom line improvements that way. I think I'm making the argument to tell them, be mindful, because it might look tempting to automate processes and take people out for cost savings. But in the long run, you're going to be undermining longer-term performance and the company as a whole. And you've put your finger on it. In a way, it's because senior leaders tend to underestimate. They think, yes, sure, it hurts people that we make redundant. They underestimate the impact it has on the other 90% that stay. And that's not something they think much about. But the reality is, if you see your colleagues being taken out because of AI, then one, typically you care about these other people, and second, you start worrying about your own job security. And it means that your well-being drops. It means that you become less productive for the causal reasons that we've described before. It means that you're less likely to stay at the organization because you think, well, if they replace people at the first hint of possibility, then why would I stay? There's also more other elements that are more specific to AI. If you see that AI is being deployed in order to take people out, then you'll have some natural skepticism and resilience, or natural—you're not going to be all too excited, essentially, to start adopting it yourself if you think that adopting it means potentially the company culling people away. Now, you might be adopting out of fear because you don't want to be the person of the next batch of 10% that gets taken out. But that's not a good place to be in either, neither from an organization perspective nor as an individual perspective, certainly not from a well-being element. And so what we also then see is that when people are actually—when there's headcount reductions, people are forced and mandated to co-opt AI, then you also find more AI workslop. So my colleagues, Kate Niederhoffer and Jeff Hancock coined this notion of workslop, AI workslop. That's really, I think, became the word of 2025 and still continues to be used because people see it all over the place. So if you have Workforces that have had headcount reductions, people poorly trained and mandated onto AI, they're overworked, stressed out, while then they have no choice but to resort to copilot and other AI tools. But they produce a lot of what looks like clean, nice work and very copious, but actually sloppy and is next to the point and doesn't actually solve any problems whatsoever, but looks fancy. What's also worrying then is that work slop gets sent out the food chain. And so, weirdly, the people who made the decisions are actually somewhat ironically, people who made the decisions for these headcount reductions, they're then the ones who get the sloppy work sent up the food chain and see these reports coming through that look fancy, but actually are completely useless or next to the point. And so there's actually more work being sent up than was in the case before because of overworked people having to rely on AI in poor ways without much training. So there's a lot of these elements that are sort of—there's an argument to be made that if you go down the automation path and do headcount reductions, then more AI work slop, less AI adoption, lower well-being, more people leaving, less retention, and ultimately also you're becoming less an employer of choice because people are not stupid. They know that your company is shrinking and that you're looking to take people out at the first possibility. And so that means that's not being an attractive employer. And then finally, there's sort of another element as well that's down the line that people tend to underestimate or senior managers tend to underestimate. We find that it's mostly junior workers, the white-collar kind, that have been taken out and their jobs. But where are your next vice presidents going to come from, your next directors? And so the company culture of training people up and having them grow through the organization into leadership positions, well, that leadership pipeline is being eroded as we speak. If you take out all your young people and the jobs that require that sort of training, and so with it will go down company culture, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Everything that sets your company apart from any other company. And so there's a whole host of reasons why, despite it being very tempting to do cost savings through headcount reduction, it will come to haunt senior leaders and boards down the line. And that's the argument we've made, is that augmentation might cost you more in the short run. So, in other words, investing in humans alongside technology and not looking to do headcount reductions in the first instance, or unless it's absolutely necessary. But we do think that will win in the long run, the augmentation piece. And that's the argument we put forward. Just to finish, sort of final question really, a bit of advice to leaders or anyone listening. If you're a manager listening, if you're a leader listening, you want to sort of, you know, you've been convinced about the case for improving wellbeing is a way to drive business success. What would be the first thing that you'd advise people, leaders to do? Is it about measurement, experimentation? What would you advise them to do? It's interesting. You obviously guessed that. As an empiricist, data, so measure what you treasure. So if you want to take wellbeing seriously, and I hope most people do, then you want to also track and measure this. And the way to measure this is easy. It's really just measuring on a relatively frequent basis: are people satisfied with their jobs? Are they happy at work? What levels of stress? Do they find purpose and meaning in the work they do? So these indicators, these KPIs for how people feel at work and about work, integrate those four items into your survey or pulses, and that will give you a good sense for whether you are doing a good job as a senior manager, and whether you're driving that in the right direction. If you can improve those metrics of workplace wellbeing, you'll see all these downstream positive consequences around productivity, retention, recruitment. And it will also give you a hint of whether your AI strategy is working and whether you're going down an augmentation or an automation path. And Emmanuel, I'm so mentally grateful for the time you've taken, and I love your work. If people are interested, I've linked to about four or five bits of your work in the show notes. Thank you so much for taking the time today. I think you're doing such important work, so valuable. Thank you, Brucey. Good luck to all. The holidays are busy enough without worrying about missed calls or customers. But just because you're swamped doesn't mean people stop calling. And if nobody picks up, that call goes to your competitor. That's why over 90,000 companies choose Quo, the business phone built for busy teams. Smart call routing sends calls to the right person. Shared numbers let your team cover for each other. And an AI agent picks up when nobody can, capturing every lead so nothing falls through the cracks. Money is on the line. Always say hello with Quo. Try Quo for free, plus get 20% off your first six months when you go to quo.com/tech. That's Q-U-O dot com slash tech. Growing businesses need systems that make fulfilling parcel or freight orders effortless. Switch to ShipStation before peak season so you're prepped before the rush hits. ShipStation connects Shopify, Amazon, TikTok Shop, and over 200 other marketplaces, integrations, and carriers within one platform. Manage orders, sync inventory, track returns, all in one place automatically. Upgrade your shipping operations to stress-proof your biggest sales days and capture every bit of potential revenue. Go to ShipStation.com and use code AUDIO and get 30 days free. You've got big plans for your money. You invest, you track, you plan ahead. But does your financial app actually help you decide what to do next? Quicken helps you go beyond balances and basic reports. Project your cash flow, dig into your investments, and use Quicken AI to understand what matters across your finances. With Quicken, you can make sense of your options and decide what to do next. Quicken. Know what to do next. See how at Quicken.com. Thank you, Yann Emmanuel. Like I say, I've linked to lots of the things we discussed in the show notes. As ever, if you're interested in this or anything related to making your work better, the best place to start is in the weekly newsletter, and you can see that linked to in the show notes. I've been Bruce Daisley. Thank you for your company today. I'll see you next time. 500 orders a month was manageable. 5,000 is madness. Embrace intelligent order fulfillment with ShipStation, the only platform combining order management, warehouse workflows, LTL freight shipments, inventory, returns, and analytics in one place. What used to take five separate tools, ShipStation does in one. Automate fulfillment and rate shopping for parcel and freight to ship more with up to 90% savings. Go to ShipStation.com and use code XXX to try ShipStation free for 60 days. Cash now, more later. From OpenDoor gives you cash up front for your home plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later. Skip the showings now, pocket extra profit later. This is so simple now. This is so awesome later. Or sell fast now and pop the champagne later. Cash now, more later. Now available nationwide. Start your offer at opendoor.com/acast. Profits calculated after fees and costs. Eligibility and offer price may vary. The Quarter Pounder with Cheese is made with 100% fresh beef, cooked when you order it. Then comes the melted cheese, the slivered onions, the pickles, the ketchup, and the mustard. Add hot, crispy fries and an ice-cold Coke, all for $8. And if things go well, one loose fry at the bottom of the bag. The Quarter Pounder with Cheese meal, now $8. Ba da ba ba ba.